All states›Cookie Shops›New York›Oyster Bay

Cookie Shops in Oyster Bay, NY

3 of the 13 bakeries we list in Oyster Bay have cookies.

Every bakery here has cookies in its name or category, or names cookies on its own website.

  1. Francesco's Bakery

    640 S Broadway, Oyster Bay, NY 11801

    Custom cakesCookies
    Call Website Directions

  2. Merritt Bakery

    315 Northwest Dr, Oyster Bay, NY 11735

    CookiesGluten-freeVegan
    Call Website Directions

  3. Brooklyn Delights

    848 main street, Frank Ave #1, Oyster Bay, NY 11735

    CookiesGluten-free
    Call Directions
Ask about boxes. Cookies are often sold by the piece, in a half dozen or by the dozen, and many shops take large orders for events with a day of notice.

Also in Oyster Bay

More in Oyster Bay and New York

Cookie Shops near Oyster Bay

Good to know

Can I order cookies in bulk?

Many cookie shops take advance orders for parties and offices; call a day or two before.