All states›Custom Cake Bakeries›Indiana

Custom Cake Bakeries in Indiana

40 of the 882 bakeries we track in Indiana have custom and made-to-order cakes. Full listings for every city are on the Indiana page.

40bakeries
24cities
882bakeries statewide

Custom cakes — birthday, wedding, themed and sculpted — take design and baking time that a shop with a display case does not always offer. Every bakery here names custom or made-to-order cakes on its own website.

Indianapolis 10

  1. Vanilla Bean Bakery

    1510 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  2. The Cake Bake Shop

    6515 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220

    CakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  3. Hart Bakery & Gifts

    7030 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46219

    Custom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  4. Kim's Kakery

    5452 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227

    CupcakesCustom cakesGluten-free
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  5. Sweet Escape Cake Company

    7745 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakesFrenchCookiesGluten-freeVegan
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  6. Cretia Cakes Bake Shop

    4640 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  7. Cretia Cakes Bake Shop

    6066 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  8. The Cheesecake Lady

    3002 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46208

    Custom cakes
    Website All Indianapolis

  9. Vanilla Bean Bakery

    2324 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260-1906

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call All Indianapolis

  10. Zoë's World Of Cakes

    2442 Central Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205-4329

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakes
    Website All Indianapolis

Carmel 3

  1. The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers

    Upper Deck, 799 Hanover Place Ste 260, Carmel, IN 46032

    CakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Carmel

  2. Cretia Cakes Bake Shop

    1435 Chase Ct, Carmel, IN 46032-7502

    CakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Carmel

  3. No Label At The Table

    111 W Main St Ste 145, Carmel, IN 46033

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookiesGluten-free
    Website All Carmel

Bloomington 2

  1. Baked

    115 N Washington St, Bloomington, IN 47408-3579

    Custom cakesCookiesGluten-freeVegan
    Call Website All Bloomington

  2. Rainbow Bakery

    201 S Rogers St, Bloomington, IN 47404

    Custom cakes
    Call Website All Bloomington

Fort Wayne 2

  1. Icing For Izaac

    243 Airport North Office Park, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Fort Wayne

  2. Sassie Cakes

    2801 Lower Huntington Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46809

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Fort Wayne

New Albany 2

  1. Sweet Stuff Bakery

    323 E Spring St, New Albany, IN 47150

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All New Albany

  2. Rookies Cookies

    310 Pearl St, New Albany, IN 47150-3418

    Custom cakesCookies
    Call Website All New Albany

Peru 2

  1. Just Desserts By Wendy

    154 N Grant St, Peru, IN 46970-1903

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Peru

  2. Just Desserts By Wendy

    210 Boulevard, Peru, IN 46970

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Peru

Plainfield 2

  1. Molly’s Sociable Sweets

    1601 E Main St, Plainfield, IN 46168

    CupcakesCustom cakes
    Call Website All Plainfield

  2. BrewLab's Mama Bird Bakery Inc.

    234 E Main St Ste 103, Plainfield, IN 46168

    Custom cakes
    Call Website All Plainfield

Borden 1

  1. Sandy's Custom Cakes

    414 E Water St, Borden, IN 47106

    CakesCustom cakes
    Call Website

Brownsburg 1

  1. Sweet Paige's

    40 E Main St, Brownsburg, IN 46112

    CupcakesCustom cakesFrenchCookies
    Call Website All Brownsburg

Evansville 1

  1. Piece of Cake

    210 Main St, Evansville, IN 47708

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakesGluten-free
    Call Website All Evansville

Goshen 1

  1. Sweet-Em's Cake Shoppe

    1920 Elkhart Rd, Goshen, IN 46526

    CakesCustom cakes
    Call Website All Goshen

Highland 1

  1. Cakes By Karen

    8632 Kennedy Ave, Highland, IN 46322-1623

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakes
    Call Website All Highland

Hobart 1

  1. Marilyn's Bakery

    8960 E Ridge Rd, Hobart, IN 46342

    Custom cakesCookies
    Call Website

Kouts 1

  1. Desserts by Juliette

    401 S Main St, Kouts, IN 46347

    Custom cakes
    Call Website

Lagrange 1

  1. Foltz Bakery

    122 S Detroit St, Lagrange, IN 46761

    Custom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Lagrange

Lebanon 1

  1. Titus Bakery

    820 W South St, Lebanon, IN 46052

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Lebanon

Monticello 1

  1. 10.10 Bakery

    128 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Monticello

Seymour 1

  1. Batar

    12649 E US-50, Seymour, IN 47274-8518

    Custom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Seymour

South Bend 1

  1. Sugarpaste

    2211 S Michigan St, South Bend, IN 46613-2321

    CakesCustom cakes
    Call All South Bend

Valparaiso 1

  1. KupKates Custom Cakes

    206 Elm St Ste 208, Valparaiso, IN 46383

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakes
    Call Website All Valparaiso

Warsaw 1

  1. Cake Lady

    2475 E Pierceton Rd, Warsaw, IN 46580

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakes
    Call Website All Warsaw

Westfield 1

  1. Titus Bakery and Deli

    17471 Wheeler Rd, Westfield, IN 46074-6902

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website All Westfield

Whiting 1

  1. Calumet Bakery

    1446 119th St, Whiting, IN 46394

    Custom cakes
    Call Website

Winfield 1

  1. Saturday Sangria Bakery & Cafe

    10719 Randolph St, Winfield, IN 46307

    CupcakesCustom cakesCookiesGluten-free
    Call Website
Start with a consultation. Many bakeries book a call or tasting for wedding and large cakes and ask for a deposit; bring a date, a headcount and a picture of what you like.

Also in Indiana

Good to know

How far ahead should I order a custom cake?

Often one to two weeks for a birthday cake and several weeks to months for a wedding cake; popular dates fill early.

How much does a custom cake cost?

Price depends on size, flavor and decoration, and many bakeries quote per serving or after a consultation, so ask for a quote.