All states›Custom Cake Bakeries›New York›Buffalo

Custom Cake Bakeries in Buffalo, NY

7 of the 52 bakeries we list in Buffalo have custom and made-to-order cakes.

Custom cakes — birthday, wedding, themed and sculpted — take design and baking time that a shop with a display case does not always offer. Every bakery here names custom or made-to-order cakes on its own website.

  1. Fairy Cakes Cupcakery

    289 Parkside Ave, Buffalo, NY 14214

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakesCookies
    Call Website Directions

  2. Wheatberry Bake Shop

    3985 Harlem Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226-4707

    Custom cakesBreadVegan
    Call Website Directions

  3. Ohlson's Bakery & Cafe

    8500 Sheridan Dr, Buffalo, NY 14221-6243

    CupcakesCustom cakesItalianCookiesGluten-free
    Call Website Directions

  4. Fig Tree Patisserie

    3062 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217

    CakesCustom cakesFrenchItalianCookiesGluten-freeVegan
    Call Website Directions

  5. Frost Artisan Bakery

    1197 Niagara St, Buffalo, NY 14213

    CupcakesCustom cakesItalianCookiesBread
    Call Website Directions

  6. Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery

    27 Chandler St # 214a, Buffalo, NY 14207-2401

    CakesCustom cakes
    Call Website Directions

  7. Cakes By Katya

    1132 E Lovejoy St, Buffalo, NY 14206-1129

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakes
    Call Website Directions
Start with a consultation. Many bakeries book a call or tasting for wedding and large cakes and ask for a deposit; bring a date, a headcount and a picture of what you like.

Also in Buffalo

More in Buffalo and New York

Custom Cake Bakeries near Buffalo

Good to know

How far ahead should I order a custom cake?

Often one to two weeks for a birthday cake and several weeks to months for a wedding cake; popular dates fill early.

How much does a custom cake cost?

Price depends on size, flavor and decoration, and many bakeries quote per serving or after a consultation, so ask for a quote.