All states›Custom Cake Bakeries›New York›Ithaca

Custom Cake Bakeries in Ithaca, NY

4 of the 11 bakeries we list in Ithaca have custom and made-to-order cakes.

Custom cakes — birthday, wedding, themed and sculpted — take design and baking time that a shop with a display case does not always offer. Every bakery here names custom or made-to-order cakes on its own website.

  1. The Rolling Pops

    166 Pinckney Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850

    Custom cakesCookies
    Call Website Directions

  2. Rashida Sawyer Bakery

    110 W Green St, Ithaca, NY 14850-5420

    Custom cakesItalianGluten-free
    Call Website Directions

  3. Rashida Sawyer Bakery

    808 S Meadow St, Ithaca, NY 14850-5323

    Custom cakesItalianGluten-free
    Call Website Directions

  4. Sarah's Patisserie

    200 Pleasant Grove Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850

    CupcakesCakesCustom cakesFrenchCookies
    Call Directions
Start with a consultation. Many bakeries book a call or tasting for wedding and large cakes and ask for a deposit; bring a date, a headcount and a picture of what you like.

Also in Ithaca

More in Ithaca and New York

Custom Cake Bakeries near Ithaca

Good to know

How far ahead should I order a custom cake?

Often one to two weeks for a birthday cake and several weeks to months for a wedding cake; popular dates fill early.

How much does a custom cake cost?

Price depends on size, flavor and decoration, and many bakeries quote per serving or after a consultation, so ask for a quote.